Systematic Needs vs. Individual Needs.....The Push and Pull

 This past month I’ve said goodbye to both the Panorama and Orient-Macksburg community school systems. While reflecting on both good and hard times at each district, I started to focus on a unique challenge for superintendent leaders.  What happens when caring for individuals within the system clashes with caring for the system.   As I transition into my new position, I can tell you that I already have a deep passion and I care greatly for my new school district.  That being said I have only met a handful of our employees, parents, students and community members.  It is my belief that a superintendent has to care immediately for their system.  On the surface it seems obvious, “what’s good for the system is good for the individuals within it.”  But is this always the case?


Our good friends in the artificial intelligence arena suggested the following key points when asked about this topic.


K-12 superintendents play a crucial role in caring for both the overall school system and the individuals within it. Their responsibilities encompass managing the educational institution as a whole while also addressing the needs of students, teachers, administrators, and other staff members. Here are some ways in which superintendents care for their school systems and individuals within the system:


Caring for the School System:

  1. Strategic Planning: Superintendents develop long-term strategic plans to enhance the overall quality of education within the school system. They set goals, establish policies, and create initiatives to drive improvements across the district.

  2. Budgeting and Resource Allocation: Superintendents manage the financial resources of the school system, ensuring that funds are allocated appropriately to support various programs, facilities, and staff members.

  3. Curriculum Development: Superintendents oversee the development and implementation of a robust curriculum that aligns with educational standards, addresses the needs of the students, and promotes academic growth.

  4. Policy Implementation: Superintendents are responsible for enforcing policies and regulations mandated by the school board, state or federal authorities. They ensure compliance with legal requirements and promote a safe and inclusive learning environment.


Caring for Individuals within the System:

  1. Support for Teachers and Staff: Superintendents provide guidance, professional development opportunities, and resources to teachers and staff members. They promote a positive work environment and address concerns or challenges faced by educators.

  2. Student Support Services: Superintendents collaborate with counselors, psychologists, and other support staff to develop programs and initiatives that address the social, emotional, and academic needs of students. Superintendents may implement interventions and support services for students with special needs or those facing challenging circumstances.

  3. Parent and Community Engagement: Superintendents foster strong relationships with parents, guardians, and community members. They create avenues for open communication, seek feedback, and involve stakeholders in decision-making processes that impact the education system.

  4. Crisis Management: Superintendents ensure the safety and well-being of individuals within the school system by implementing emergency preparedness plans, addressing crises or incidents, and coordinating with local authorities as necessary.


There are times when system needs vs. individual needs collide.  These clashes can arise due to various factors, including limited resources, differing priorities, and competing interests. Below are a few scenarios:


  • Fiscal Allocation: Superintendents may need to make difficult decisions regarding the allocation of limited resources, such as budgetary constraints or staffing limitations.  What specifically comes to my mind is during negotiation sessions.  In both of my former district employees are underpaid as they are in most public schools.  While the superintendent and board teamwork to provide the very best financial package, they must balance that with the system's financial needs. 

  • Curriculum and Instruction: Developing and implementing a curriculum that meets the needs of diverse learners is a tall task.  Marzano High Reliability Schools research suggests, “High-quality instruction is the most important tool educators have at their disposal to positively affect student learning.”  I completely agree but at times this philosophy could collide with accommodating individual students' unique learning styles and needs.  What a challenge our educators have.

  • Behavior Management:  Welcome to the “no win world” of being a public education principal where every parent wants other people’s children punished to the fullest extent possible for every single infraction.  Balancing building needs vs. individual student well-being and individual circumstances of students can be challenging. 

  • Stakeholder Priorities: Superintendents need to manage the expectations and priorities of various stakeholders. Differing interests of these groups may fragment your learning community.  As our society becomes more polarized politically so do our learning communities and stakeholder groups.  This makes for a unique challenge to care for the needs of the system as a whole vs. individuals in a way that satisfies everyone.


As I begin my journey at Norwalk, I’m mindful of the balance between caring for the individuals within the system and caring for the system as a whole. While my passion and immediate focus lie with my new school district, I recognize the importance of nurturing the system itself for the benefit of everyone involved. Superintendents have to be considerate of both the individuals within the system to support a system where there is success for all. 


I will also mention my failure as a blogger by not tying cycling into this post, at the same time I have failed as a cyclist during my transition period of selling/buying a home and moving to a new community.  Poor food habits have become the norm.  Better days ahead but #nobaddays

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Consistency....The Holy Grail

This morning, while I was out for my usual walk, I was thinking about consistency. With December wrapping up, it’s that time when we all start thinking about our New Year's resolutions. For me, staying consistent has always been tough. Shedding weight always seemed feasible, but sustaining it? That's proven to be a real struggle over the years. Speaking of consistency, my last blog entry dates back to October, aiming for a monthly post. I used to love riding my bike, clocking over 8,000 miles a year. But now? I can’t even get excited about a casual ride. I’ve always admired folks who seem to stay consistent with everything they do. Take my old coach, for example. He's about to retire but looks like he’s twenty years younger, always in good shape and strong in his faith. So, what’s the secret to sticking with things? Why is it so hard? One thing that’s clear is habits. Doing something regularly makes it easier over time. Once it becomes a habit, it doesn’t take as much effor
Read more

Chicken or the Egg .....Vulnerability or Trust

Image
Chicken or the Egg …. Trust or Vulnerability At some point the stars align! April 4, 2023 turned out not to be another normal day.  I’m not sure what had gotten into me, but on this day I decided it was time for a wardrobe update.  It was the first day in quite some time that I donned a sports jacket and collared shirt.  It was a Tuesday and I was scheduled to attend a superintendent meeting at our area education agency.  Having two board packets to complete over the next few days, I was sure that I would not be a gracious audience member.  However, this morning Dr. Timothy D. Kanold caught my attention almost immediately. Dr. Kanold is an award winning author who works with Solution Tree and was here to discuss educator wellness .  His newest book titled: Educator Wellness: A Guide for Sustaining Physical, Mental, Emotional, and Social Well-Being (Actionable Steps for Self-Care, Health, and Wellness for Teachers and Educators) was his focus. At some point during his presentation Dr.
Read more

What do you say to a bunch of smart kids? My NHS induction speech!

Image
  Thank you, it's an honor to stand before all of you. Over the past few months, I’ve been asked to speak to our football team, read to a first grade class, and to visit with the volleyball team.  But this is quite an honor.  Over the years as a principal and superintendent  I’ve listened to a number of national honor society speeches for many people much more distinguished than I.   With that pressure on my shoulders, I thought I would think more like the kids and utilize Artificial Intelligence to write my speech.  So here we go. Ladies and gentlemen, esteemed faculty, proud parents, and, most importantly, our exceptional students.  Today, I stand before you with immense pride and honor as we gather to celebrate the induction of our remarkable students into the National Honor Society. This is a momentous occasion, not just for these outstanding young individuals but also for our entire school community. A1 then went on to talk about the pillars, the foundation of the honor societ
Read more